The suicide of the Labour party

classic Classic list List threaded Threaded
20 messages Options
John Kelly John Kelly
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

The suicide of the Labour party

The Labour party grew out of the realisation that when the worker understands the power of his contribution to the wealth of employer he can actually effect and share in the profitability of his employers business if the workers unite to improve their lot through a single voice.

Paradoxically as a former Tory I have much empathy with the morals and ambitions of those long dead social reformers such as Kier Hardy who fought so hard to improve the lives of the working classes!
 However once the socialist movement expanded from the factory floor to the floor of the House of Commons it was exposed to the intrigue and dishonesty of the world of politics which is founded on the principle of absolute corruption, ultimately corrupting everyone absolutely, it should be noted that successive Lab9ur politicians have embraced that liturgy with open arms as long as they were the direct beneficiaries.

Every time Labour have won power they have allowed power to corrupt it's plans and consequently to fail the very people who put them in power.

Now over a hundred years on we are witnessing the Labour party tearing itself apart to such a degree that whoever wins the leadership contest will set the seal of unelctability on the Labour movement for the foreseeable future perhaps forever!
Peter. C Peter. C
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

CONTENTS DELETED
The author has deleted this message.
John Kelly John Kelly
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

Peter C

Corbyn has won again with an increased majority, however exit poles conducted by Labour indicate that party members who were registered prior to the 2015 leadership contest did not vote for Corbyn.
As an interested and impartial observer I have to question the motive's of those who paid £30 for the right to join up and vote!
How many will vote for Labour in 2020? How many have voted for Corbyn in order to keep Labour in opposition? Is their any honesty in politics? I think not!
Peter. C Peter. C
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

CONTENTS DELETED
The author has deleted this message.
Mary S Mary S
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

I will now join the Labour Party and will vote Labour in the next election. I have waited 50 years, my entire voting life for a socialist government. I have always been a Labour supporter and was very hopeful when Blair won power but although his government did do some excellent things the Iraq war and the intervention in Afghanistan was a massive mistake and illegal.  Blair proved to be as arrogant and omnipotent as Thatcher. Also it was very disappointing to see Brown follow the same economics policies as Thatcher, which prevail to this day and caused the banking crisis. The bankers still have not been bought to book!
I hope that Jeremy can, somehow, unite the party, I suspect it will be one hell of a struggle but it has to be done in order to win next time. It is imperative that we have an opposition that can challenge this government. Cameron, the spineless, lazy, useless lump has gone, thank goodness.  I heard a remark recently about Cameron - he was asked about his rather small majority and he said - "not a problem for me, I am now on the board". I always did think he was under the illusion that he had a right to be PM - that was his ambition and he made it - all utterly revolting. Osborne and Johnson are waiting in the wings to see May fail - the thought of either of them in power makes me feel physically sick! I think both Osborne and Johnson believe that they should be in power - it is their right just like Cameron, they too think they should be 'on the board'.  I doubt that Jeremy Corbyn would not think like that - he has principles and ambitions which are about making the country function for everyone - socialist principles. The fact that he is a socialist also does not make him anti-capitalist as the press keep harping on about - he just wants capitalism to be fair for all and not just the wealthy few. The press and the establishment absolutely loathe and fear him and continue to berate, lambast and pour out the usual venom about him and John McDonnell and anyone who supports him. He has risen about most of the media remarks sensibly offering no response and I just hope he continues to do more of the same and continue to keep spelling out the Labour Party policies. The one thing he must do is be more challenging of the government - not respond to May's pathetic attempts at humour and undermining and really confront them. They are not particularly strong - they are hiding discontent in their own party and running around like headless chickens about Brexit - they are divided themselves.
I think there is a general feeling across the western world that people are sick of the inequality and working their guts out for wealthy lazy b.....ds like Philip Green lounging around in the Med on his £10 million yacht caring nothing for all those BHS workers who have lost their jobs. No sign of him getting the pension 'sorted'! I think there are changes afoot if the people can dislodge the old and mainstream parties - it time for the old lot to go and the new to get a chance to make substantial and necessary changes the western world needs and very very soon!
David A David A
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

In reply to this post by John Kelly
I think, Mary, you will discover that Jeremy Corbyn arrived too late for the Labour Party after those complete tossers the Millibands between them put paid to any resuscitation into this dying dinosaur, some would say already dead, and the rudderless caucus reacting like headless chickens, while blinkered Theresa May has the luxury of decidely lame humour with her jibes and jabs from the sidelines - she really doesn't do a very good impersonation of Maggie, even if she thinks she does, and I have yet to see substance in her policies, if she has any, but I fear she will drift along wherever the flow takes her, but I fear Jeremy's goose has lost its feathers and will probably succumb ere long!

Labour's day, I fear is done. They blew it in Scotland, and now they've blown it in the rest of the UK!
David A
Mary S Mary S
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

Goodness, David, I do hope you are wrong. Political parties have been known to rise from the ashes. They were out of power for a long time during Thatcher's time but did return albeit as Tory lites under Blair. I think there is a movement across the western world for change - the left and right in Europe are significant although not getting into power and I was amazed that Bernie Sanders was even visible during the recent campaigns in the US.  There is so much inequality in the west and austerity has served to anger the public and they are sick and tired of the effects of globalisation and the greed of the wealthy.  it is time for change and it may well come maybe not with Jeremy Corbyn but sooner or later. I do not think the Labour Party is dead - it took so long for it to establish itself with the likes of Kier Hardy [my Mum was dragged along by my Granddad to hear him when she was a child]. Inequality in those days was of course much more noticeable but it is relative.  My Granddad was a guard on the railways and a keen socialist and I am proud to say that I follow in his footsteps  - he would be inordinately pleased if he knew! I am very fearful of the right, also rising in popularity across Europe - the Hungarian president is terrifying and Marine Le Pen and her ilk make my skin crawl.  We need to combat those political types!
As for May - I think you may well be correct especially if she remains in power. I know you are a fan of Thatcher and that is where you and I part company. I loathed her with her bullying ways and May does not have the same personality certainly in terms of her charisma and power.  I think too that she has no policies and has tried to distract us by her support for grammar schools and it will not work. The public want to see action and as yet she is like a damp squib. The only pleasure I have from her rise is the back of Cameron and Osborne and hopefully the fall of Johnson.
Labour is finished in Scotland as the SNP is left-wing and has nothing to gain from having Labour MPs.
I do hope you are wrong as we need a credible opposition if only to hold the government to account.  
I see that various people have started to post again. I contacted Nabble and was informed they no longer exist.  The site seems to be operating, long may it continue.  I look forward to seeing more posts from everyone - Peter, John you and all the other regulars!
Peter. C Peter. C
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

This post was updated on .
CONTENTS DELETED
The author has deleted this message.
David A David A
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

In reply to this post by John Kelly
I'll go further. If I have to choose between May and Corbyn (what a thought), record wise, I favour Corbyn! So what am I saying? Simply that the days of party are, in my book over. I would like to see a revival of Ancient Greece and Athens under Xenophon whereby individuals were elected by a public vote to serve in government, the nine presidents elected by tribal vote and this state of affairs could be reviewed and individuals endorsed, if they pulled their weight, or kicked out if they didn't! That to me, seems a much better formula for government in our volatile world! and it worked! I quote from Hammond's History of Greece to 322 BC. "the city of Athena had many outstanding qualities. It gave its citizens freedom in politics, speech, education, law, and business.It fed its poor, and it gave them self-respect. It conducted the relations of daily life with humanity (philanthropia) towards the metics and slaves, who were admitted to many forms of family and state worship and received protection under the law. It led the world in culture commerce and capitalism." so there!
David A
Peter. C Peter. C
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

CONTENTS DELETED
The author has deleted this message.
Peter. C Peter. C
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

In reply to this post by David A
CONTENTS DELETED
The author has deleted this message.
Mary S Mary S
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

Peter - I, too,  do not think Labour is dead. I also agree that Jeremy must not go too far to the left as he will really frighten off the old Labour supporters and any voter fed up with Tory and cLabour capitalism, and with Blairism which was Tory by another name in many respects, but not all! His government did some good things but they have been overshadowed by the illegal war [for which he has never been bought to book - he is a war criminal and should stand trial along with Bush Jnr.]
I also think Tory capitalism has failed and the Labour Party under Corbyn could offer a realistic and workable system to replace the casino in the city, regulation of the financial and banking system and reduce the Thatcher [failed] vision of the free-market to the dustbin of history, where it belongs. We could have a decent NHS, education, social care, transport system and hopefully a sustainable and more equal society.  A workforce that is skilled and paid appropriately without the need for tax credits which allow employers to pay low wages and make larger profits.
I know there are many doubters and critics who harp on about the Corbyn politics as out of date and unrealistic but it is time for change. The sooner May and her minions are gone the better. Brexit needs to be executed and a lot of hard work needing to be done to support the UK and its future. May and her ministers are simply not up to the job and are currently scurrying around desperately trying to work out what to do and behaving like headless chickens - putting off the inevitable by trying to distract the electorate by putting forward policies, not in their mandate, to build more grammar schools.  [Yet another policy that is fundamentally flawed!]
Peter. C Peter. C
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

CONTENTS DELETED
The author has deleted this message.
Peter. C Peter. C
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

In reply to this post by Mary S
CONTENTS DELETED
The author has deleted this message.
John Kelly John Kelly
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

Because Corbyn is to politics what a traffic warden is to normal society, a person who suddenly finds themselves with a degree of power over others that in normal life has otherwise evaded them.
Mary S Mary S
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

In reply to this post by Peter. C
Crazy idea - maybe some people at the conference and not Corbyn. It was Smith [a no-mark'] who was going on about a 2nd referendum so hopefully that stupid idea will sink without trace!
I absolutely agree it all about getting Brexit started and a good deal for the UK.
I think the idea of cherry picking from UKIP should be done with great care - some of their policies were totally un-socialist - I remember reading one of their manifestos and it was very right-wing. They should definitely broach immigration as it is a major reason why Brexit won and it needs to be discussed sensibly. I have said this before - we should not be importing staff in order to reduce wages and to avoid educating and training up our own - this has always been a huge beef for me. We should be spending money on training and skilling-up our own whether they be old or young and then we would not have to import cheap labour. We should make it worthwhile for doctors and nurses to stay in this country and then we wouldn't need to employ imported staff in the NHS and of course very expensive agency staff. The same applies to social care, elderly care and education - we have changed the face of public services by becoming reliant on imported labour, as well as starving all public services and infrastructure of money [ one of Osborne's brilliant ideas about balancing the books - it worked so well!] - this must change and Brexit is a great opportunity to do so and a great stance for the Labour Party to take on board - it would be popular.
The Labour Party now has a great opportunity to use Brexit to introduce some socialist policies and get the country back on it's feet with a growth in equality, good tax receipts from reasonable wages and raising taxes from those can afford it. They could stop tax evasion and stop foreigners buying up property as investments - these people should be made to pay a huge tax for the benefit of having property here.  This could help with house pricing. The housing bubble that Carney and Osborne have divised, in order to promote growth when all it did was raise house prices and look like growth in the economy. It has been a disaster for London and the South East and spreading like a cancer. Building has not kept pace with demand and prices are too high for the average person to buy or rent. They have managed to decimate communities.  They want people to buy, as house owners are likely to vote Tory,  so are not keen to build social housing. Frankly they are a disgrace and May will not change those policies or at least I doubt it. Another great opportunity for the Labour Party if and when the stop squabbling and behave like adults and unite!
At present power has not corrupted Jeremy Corbyn - he has waited all his political life to put his socialist ideas into practice - he probably doesn't want to compromise. He has always stuck to his strong beliefs and he is well known for dislike of inequality, our elitist and class ridden society and very importantly, poking our noses into other countries' business and involving ourselves in unnecessary wars, especially if they are illegal!  He is an honest and honourable man but he will have to compromise if he is to keep the Labour Party as one - otherwise the PLC would rather see it fail than accommodate some of his ideas - they are solidly establishment and can see their future consultancies and directorships going down the drain if the socialist policies are not watered down. I can understand why he doesn't want to dilute his policies when he is in position to show the country how these could be so beneficial to our society, given that these have been held for so long and never heard or given any credence. He, now, finds himself able to broadcast these ideas and he wouldn't want to change them.  If I am correct, it is more likely that his position as leader of the party and the power associated with it will make him less corruptable, and less likely to go to his head and possibly make him more inflexible and uncompromising - this could of course lead to his downfall, along with his other enemies.
Corbyn's enemies are within his own party, and of course, the media which is mostly right-wing. They will both continue to try to destroy him and those that support him. I hope they fail and Jeremy Corbyn gets a chance to be PM and exercise some of his democratic socialism - what a change it would be after all these years of destructive conservatism and capitalism that has failed so badly!
Peter. C Peter. C
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

CONTENTS DELETED
The author has deleted this message.
Mary S Mary S
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

Thank you, Peter. We do tend to be in accord and are both staunch Labour supporter and socialists. I really don't think all is lost and hope that the party gets its act together and unites - if that happens, we stand a chance of having a Labour government. I am very keen to remain optimistic and refuse to take notice of the pessimists.
I also think that sooner or later their will be some sort of union in the party as I think their memory of the Gang of Four is still very fresh and the disaster that followed.  Hopefully the MP's who don't like Jeremy will put up and shut up after all they stand to lose out.
Anyway I intend to keep on posting and look forward to this site staying put. I have heard nothing to the contrary and nabble did not respond to my email.
John Kelly John Kelly
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

The Labour party conference has seen the newly re-elected Mr Corbin quietly sneak through a policy to hold a second EU referendum, to abandon any pretence at controlling migration from the EU or elsewhere and reaffirmed his determination to institute unlimited government borrowing to shore up the NHS, to renationalise the railways as and when the contracts of existing franchisees come to an end.

What  Mr Corbyn has not said is that his ability to carry out Government support for already partly or totally privatised organisation's would contravene EU law, so assuming he was successful at forcing a 2nd referendum and assuming the result was to remain, then his plans would be severely prejudiced by the power of Brussels.

Mr Corbyn has pledged to introduce a living wage of £10.00 per hour, and this on top of all the expenditure listed above, how will he pay for these measures? By more and more borrowing, how will he repay that borrowing? By increasing taxes!
Who in our population pay the greatest percentage of their income in taxes, the working classes, the middle classes and the upper middle classes,  not the wealthiest earners because their numbers could never generate sufficient revenues to fund such a spending program!

The fiscal logic of such promises has more holes in it than the finest Emmantile cheese, it proposes to use the same logic that a desperate individual on the lowest income would employ when consulting a loan shark in order to survive from day to day.


David A David A
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: The suicide of the Labour party

Ahem! your comparison would make a few Emmentalers blush!
David A